3 liberals, 3 different votes

Was having a beer with an investment banker at a big firm and an attorney at a small firm. The banker, a pro-life Catholic in the modern mold, voted for Obama. "First time I didn't vote Republican. But he has the leadership skills we need." The attorney, youngest in a big batch of Catholic kids, has fallen away from the Church. He challenged the banker: "I'm not Catholic anymore but I agree with the Church - there have to be membership requirements. Why vote pro-choice and be a Catholic?" It didn't sound like he voted for McCain though. I think he went libertarian. That left me.